{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home price in America has consistently exceeded the previous year's figures. However, this trend has finally come to an end. Data from October revealed that the median home sale price has dipped slightly below the same time last year, marking the first annual decrease since early 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of homes available for sale has reached its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have fallen to their lowest figures in over a decade, excluding the initial pandemic period, and around 20% of listings have experienced price reductions.

On the flip side, the cost of borrowing has risen once more. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% territory within the past week, following a brief period of lower rates. As a result, while buyers are gaining some leverage, many families are still finding monthly mortgage payments challenging to manage.

This unique situation creates an opportunity for negotiation. Sellers are encountering fewer offers and longer waits to sell, indicating that the initial listing price and terms are more of a starting conversation rather than a fixed conclusion. If you're looking for a home this winter, consider what aspects might be negotiable and how to approach these discussions with your agent and lender.

Implications of a Minor Price Decline

A national price decrease of under 0.5% doesn't signify a market crash and suggests that home values aren't declining uniformly across the board. Some high-end coastal regions with limited inventory are still witnessing price increases, whereas certain major metropolitan areas in the South and West have experienced drops of several percentage points compared to last year. It's essential to remember that local market dynamics are far more relevant than national averages.

The national statistics indicate a shift in the balance of power. With homes languishing on the market and numerous listings competing for a dwindling number of buyers, sellers are becoming more open to negotiations. This flexibility often manifests not only in price adjustments but also in the conditions of the sale.

Considering More Than Price

While many buyers concentrate solely on the purchase price, in this high-interest environment, the total monthly payment and the cash needed at closing can be even more essential. Reducing the sale price by a few thousand dollars may only provide minimal relief on your loan. Allocating funds differently can sometimes yield greater benefits. Common negotiation points in a slower market include:

  • A purchase price that is lower than the listing price
  • Credit from the seller toward your closing expenses
  • Repairs completed prior to closing, or monetary credits instead of repairs
  • Seller assistance to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing or move-in timeline that accommodates your scheduling needs
  • Included items like appliances or window treatments

Your agent understands how local sellers are reacting and can assist you in prioritizing which items to include in your offer. The aim is not to request everything but rather to focus on the aspects that will have the most significant impact on your situation.

Using Closing Cost Credits to Ease Finances

Closing costs typically account for several percent of the loan amount, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time homebuyers, gathering this cash can prove to be a significant hurdle. A seller credit can directly address these costs, allowing you to bring less cash to finalize the purchase.

However, there are limitations. Various loan programs place caps on how much a seller can contribute, often ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price, contingent on the type of loan and the size of your down payment. Generally speaking, a credit cannot surpass your actual closing costs. Consult your lender early to understand your specific loan's allowances, ensuring any requests made in your offer fall within acceptable limits.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates climbing above 7%, one of the most beneficial offerings from a seller could be assistance with your mortgage interest rate. There are generally two types of buydowns available.

A permanent buydown involves paying upfront discount points at closing to reduce your interest rate for the duration of the loan. Each point equals 1% of the loan value, and the reduction achieved varies by lender and market conditions. If you plan to maintain the mortgage for an extended period, a permanent buydown can be economically advantageous.

A temporary buydown lowers your payments for the initial year or two. In a common arrangement, the rate might be reduced by two percentage points in the first year and one point in the second, with the rate returning to its full amount thereafter. For a $350,000 30-year loan at about 7.34%, the monthly principal and interest would approximately be $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the first-year payment would decrease to around $1,952, and the second-year payment would adjust to about $2,176, before re-adjusting to the original payment in year three. Funding this type of arrangement may cost just over $8,000 in this scenario, which sellers may prefer to cover instead of lowering the price by a similar amount.

It's essential to remember that a temporary buydown isn't a long-term solution. You need to be comfortable with the full payment once the discount period concludes. Qualifying for the mortgage typically relies on the complete rate. If interest rates decrease in the future, refinancing might become a possibility, but there are no guarantees regarding timing or likelihood.

The Importance of Home Inspections

In earlier, frenzied markets, many buyers waived inspections or minimized their requests to remain competitive. In a more temperate market, there is less urgency to forgo these protections. A comprehensive home inspection provides insight into the condition of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation before you make a commitment.

If the inspection uncovers issues, your agent can assist you in determining whether to request repairs, negotiate a price reduction, or seek credits instead. Credits can often be more straightforward than having the seller take care of repairs since you can choose who does the work and how, although the best course of action will depend on the nature of the issue and your loan's stipulations.

Prepare Your Financing Ahead of Time

Having negotiating leverage is ineffective without solid financing. A seller evaluating offers typically favors the buyer who appears most likely to close. Before diving into your home search, secure a comprehensive preapproval rather than just a quick qualification. Understand your maximum comfortable monthly payment rather than solely focusing on the maximum loan amount, and compare estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire with each lender about handling seller credits or buydowns to avert any surprises down the line.

Key Questions to Review with Your Agent

  • How long are homes in this area remaining on the market, and how frequently are prices being lowered?
  • Would a reduction in price, closing cost assistance, or a rate buydown be most beneficial for my financial situation?
  • How do the specific condition and history of this property influence what I could request?
  • What contingencies should I incorporate in my offer to safeguard my interests?

The Final Takeaway

While a softer market doesn't guarantee low prices, particularly with rising mortgage rates, it does afford informed buyers greater latitude to customize their deals according to their financial capabilities. With reliable financing, an understanding of your priorities, and guidance from your agent and lender, you might be able to negotiate terms that were unimaginable just a year or two prior.

Rewritten using AI

Stay Connected

South Florida Real Estate Delivered to Your Inbox.

Join Kay’s newsletter for local market insights, featured properties, community updates, and helpful real estate advice.

Join the Newsletter No spam. Just valuable real estate updates.
Send Us a Message